Joe Gandelman, 11/26/2013 [Archive]

Martin Bashir Crosses the Line

Martin Bashir Crosses the Line

Independent's Eye by Joe Gandelman

Is it possible to go over the already distant line of acceptable discussion often nearly crossed by polarizing left and right talkers? MSNBC's Martin Bashir did in an incident that shows us how far American political "debate" has sunk.

But it's not entirely surprising.

It all started when Bashir -- the journalist-turned commentator criticized by analysts for being among the most shrill partisan hosts at MSNBC -- decided to chime in on former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin's widely criticized comment comparing U.S. indebtedness to China to American slavery.He then read from the diaries of notorious former slave-owner Thomas Thistlewood who had noted one punishment for slaves was to defecate in their mouths. Bashir then delivered this gem of 21st century political vulgarity:

"When Mrs. Palin invokes slavery, she doesn't just prove her rank ignorance," he said. "She confirms if anyone [is] truly qualified for a dose of discipline from Thomas Thistlewood, she would be the outstanding candidate."

It ignited a firestorm. The video of his commentary was replayed and embedded far and wide. Bashir apologized, but the controversy continued. Palin accepted his apology and took some more swipes at him and MSNBC. Some (who had not suggested Rush Limbaugh be fired for Limbaugh's comments about law student Sandra Fluke) suggested MSNBC parent-company NBC should pull the plug entirely on the ratings-struggling channel. Bashir had not only crossed the line but shoved political talk to a new low.

MSNBC's "Morning Joe" host Joe Scarborough called the remarks deplorable and told his viewers about Bashir's apology:"I'm glad that he went out and said it [the apology], and I will guarantee you he didn't write all that by himself."

Indeed:Bashir's comments -- scripted, edited, approved and read on the air -- reflected a mindset.

In the 60s and 70sthe late Steve Allen had a show on PBS called "The Meetings of the Minds," and David Susskind had "Open End." If these shows were re-titled to fit today's political culture, they'd have to be called "The Meetings of the Mouths" and "Open Mouth." Attempting to share ideas or convince others with the power of passionate but thoughtful arguments have little to do with today's partisan talk shows. They're about re-affirminglike-minded viewers' existing beliefs, emphasizing developments through viewers' pre-existing political conditions, channelingconfrontation, frustration, anger and partisanship -- then delivering this demographic package to advertisers.

But you can't just blame ideological talkers.

How many times on any cable channel or broadcast channel if there's a political discussion where both sides get angry, or interrupt each other, or someone makes an outrageous comment, do you see the host get a the-cat-just-ate-the-canary look and say, "We'll have to have the two of you back!" Translation: "That conflict, anger, interrupting was great TV!" If they had coolly discussed policy or indulged innuance, the host might not be re-inviting.

Meanwhile,weblogs were once considered a wave of the future that would allow citizens to become a citizen journalist with no corporate gatekeepers, and do real reporting, or serious commentary. But blogs have declined as new and "old" media companies created websites absorbing some of the style of the original weblogs and offering blog-like posts and original reporting.Many political blogs are now citizen op-ed pages or partisan blogs actively promoting one party and actively denigrating the other.

Bashir's sin was crossing a way-out-there line that has been pushed by others to a limit a continent away from broadcast or print media limits 20 years ago.We're seeing less the "dumbing down of America," than the "coarsening of America." Bashir took it to its grossest, most juvenile, vilest conclusion -- but he took an "it" that is out there. This "it" has turned some partisan talk show hosts of the right and left into millionaires, and fills the bank accountsof companies employing them. There is lucrative market for packaging partisan anger and providing a tool for lashing out.

Someday perhaps someone will name a dish to serve at restaurants that will define the quality of the serious discussion Bashir and24/7 indignant left and right partisan talkers sometimes offer. But there'salready a "pooh-pooh platter."

Copyright 2013 Joe Gandelman, distributed exclusively by Cagle Cartoons newspaper syndicate.

Joe Gandelman is a veteran journalist who wrote for newspapers overseas and in the United States. He has appeared on cable news show political panelsand is Editor-in-Chief of The Moderate Voice, an Internet hub for independents, centrists and moderates. He also writes for The Week's online edition. CNN's John Avlon named him as one of the top 25 Centrists Columnists and Commentators. He can be reached at and can be booked to speak at Follow him on Twitter:

This column has been edited by the author. Representations of fact and opinion are solely those of the author

Download Joe Gandelman's color photo - Download Joe Gandelman's black and white mug shot photo
Why not run a cartoon with the column? We recommend the cartoons below as a good compliment to Joe Gandelman's topic.
Click on the thumbnail images to preview and download the cartoons.

Related Cartoons

 Con  Media in bed with dems
By: Eric Allie

January 25, 2013

 Con  Following the narrative COLOR
By: Eric Allie

January 18, 2011

 Con  Media in bed with dems COLOR
By: Eric Allie

January 25, 2013

 Con  Following the narrative
By: Eric Allie

January 18, 2011

 Con  MSNBC Cuckoo
By: Eric Allie

February 15, 2010

We do not accept and will not review unsolicited submissions from cartoonists.
Sales & Information: (805) 969-2829
Billing Information: (805)
Technical Support:

FREE cartoons for your website if you're already a paying print subscriber!
Artwork and columns are copyrighted by each creator. All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized reproduction prohibited. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service