Joseph Cotto, 8/12/2014 [Archive]

Many American Jews Don't Support Israel

By Joseph Cotto

The ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine has renewed tensions over Zionism in an unlikely place — the United States.

Last October, long before the present crisis began, Pew Research found that "[American] Jews' feelings for Israel are equaled or even exceeded by those of white evangelical Protestants." 82 percent of these Protestants "say that Israel was given to the Jewish people by God", while 40 percent of Jews held the same belief.

Even then, support for religious Zionism was largely defined by which denomination of Judaism one belongs to. 84 percent of Orthodox Jews agreed with white evangelicals, as did 54 percent of Conservative Jews. In the Reform community, support plummeted to 35 percent. Only 24 percent of Nondenominational Jews agreed with the idea of a Jewish divine right to Israel.

In late July, the advocacy group Jewish Voices for Peace released an Internet video condemning human rights violations supposedly committed by Israeli forces. The video depicted celebrities, including feminist academic Gloria Steinem, film director Jonathan Demme, and Anglican Archbishop Desmond Tutu, protesting violence against Palestinians.

While narrating the video, playwright Wallace Shawn claimed that "(f)or decades, Palestinians have endured statelessness, occupation, dispossession, and a lack of basic rights while Israel has steadily taken their land and denied their freedom. Holding the people of Gaza under a seven-year siege has only brought more suffering, not peace."

According to JVP, from July 7 to July 18 alone, Israel ended the lives of more than 250 Palestinians. All of these fatalities occurred in the Gaza Strip, and 80 percent of those killed are said to be civilians. Of the casualties, 44 apparently are children.

While it is rare to hear much in opposition to Israel among the ranks of America's leading Jewish-interest organizations, this was not always so. Until World War II, the American Jewish establishment was decidedly anti-Zionist or, at the very least, not prone to public gestures of support for the ideology.

The Holocaust changed this completely. Its ramifications on American Jewish life were so wide-reaching that Reform Judaism, which stressed social assimilation so much that its services were often conducted on Sundays, began to take an entirely different liturgical approach.

Congregations increased the use of Hebrew, advanced arguments of ethnic Jewish peoplehood, and emphasized religious rituals thought to be long outdated, such as the bar mitzvah. Ethical universalism and an outright refutation of ethnocentrism, both of which had been central to Reform since its establishment in 19th-century Germany, were generally abandoned.

An organization called the "American Council for Judaism" was founded as a counterreformation of sorts. Not only was it opposed to prevailing liturgical shifts, but it passionately campaigned against the possibility of Israeli patriotism among American Jews. The ACJ was mainly backed by affluent, if not wealthy, native-born conservatives who lived in the South, Midwest, or Pacific West.

Ultimately, the ACJ became a pariah for the next generation of American Jewish leaders. Today, it has scant membership and is often treated as a non-entity by most American Jews, if they even know of its existence.

"You know, it's my view that if the Nazi period had not existed, if the Holocaust had never happened, none of what we're facing in the Middle East would occur," Allan C. Brownfeld, the ACJ's publications editor, recently said on Cotto & Company, my online radio program. "You know, the Palestinians say, 'Hitler killed six million Jews. This was a terrible thing. We didn't do it. Why was our land taken from us to make up for what the Germans did to the Jews?' This is a difficult question.

"The Holocaust has made many American Jews feel that they must support Israel whatever it does, somehow identifying the Palestinians as a group in a long line of anti-Jewish forces in history. But this is not true. You remember in 1492, when the Jews were expelled from Catholic Spain, they were welcomed into the Ottoman Empire, of which Palestine was a part. Jews and Muslims have lived peacefully for thousands of years together."


Copyright 2014 Joseph Cotto, distributed exclusively by Cagle Cartoons newspaper syndicate.

Joseph Cotto is a historical and social journalist, and writes about politics, economics and social issues. Email him at

This column has been edited by the author. Representations of fact and opinions are solely those of the author.

Download Joseph Cotto's color photo - Download Joseph Cotto's black and white mug shot photo
Why not run a cartoon with the column? We recommend the cartoons below as a good compliment to Joseph Cotto's topic.
Click on the thumbnail images to preview and download the cartoons.

Related Cartoons

Playing Israel vs Palestinians COLOR
By: Daryl Cagle
August 4, 2014

Playing Israel vs Palestinians
By: Daryl Cagle
August 4, 2014

Weapons to Israel
By: Steve Sack

August 5, 2014

Weapons to Israel B/W
By: Steve Sack

August 5, 2014

Netayahu's War
By: Patrick Chappatte

August 1, 2014

Surgical strike
By: David Fitzsimmons

August 5, 2014

Surgical strike Color
By: David Fitzsimmons

August 5, 2014

Israel Proportional Response COLOR
By: Dario Castillejos

August 5, 2014

We do not accept and will not review unsolicited submissions from cartoonists.
Sales & Information: (805) 969-2829
Billing Information: (805)
Technical Support:

FREE cartoons for your website if you're already a paying print subscriber!
Artwork and columns are copyrighted by each creator. All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized reproduction prohibited. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service