Brian O''Neill Brian O''Neill, 1/13/2010 [Archive]

Yemen is Not Afghanistan

Yemen is Not Afghanistan

By Brian O'Neill

The subtext of the question that has been echoing around media and policy circles the last few weeks- what to do about Yemen- has been a discussion about where Yemen is going.The question that has been asked, repeatedly, is if Yemen is the next Afghanistan, or, with a little more nuance to the story, if it is the next Somalia.However, it is neither or these.Lost in comparison is the simple truth, seemingly too obvious to merit mention: it is nothing except the current Yemen.

I know it seems tautological- Yemen is Yemen- but I think it is something that policy-makers need to keep reminding themselves.The language that we use shapes policy, and if we gear our policy to avoid a 'new Afghanistan' we'll be boxing ourselves into the ideas and strategies that shaped our Afghan plan.Essentially, we will be fighting the last war.

On the surface, the comparisons make sense.Like Afghanistan, Yemen is a mountainous, fractured country without a strong tradition of central government, and with a history of Islamist ideology (the mountains are interesting as more than just a quirk of geology; in an under-developed country, mountains tend to separate culture and inhibit a sense of nation). Somalia looks like the nightmare template for Yemen's future: a lawless, tribal land of pre-modern government and post-modern weaponry.

But Yemen is neither of these.For starters, while Afghanistan is a country that is ethnically divided, with the Pashtun population more connected with their brethren in Pakistan, Yemen, for whatever its political divisions, is uniformly Yemeni.There are a multitude of ideas about what this means.Some want a republic, some a tribal confederation, some a secular democracy, for a few an Islamist-government.But there is no doubt that people want their version of Yemen, a land that while not connected has for millennia has a sense of self. Even the mountains are part of the creation myth, rather than just a military fastness.

There is a one-letter difference to the challenges, one that sounds uncomfortably like vague and squishy poly-sci lingo, but is actually very important. In Afghanistan (and Iraq), the trick is to bring together various peoples.In Yemen, it is to deal with various people.Please don't take that as some kind of Pollyanna sentiment; the difficulty of the task is enormous.But even the religious differences- Sunni vs. Shia- are far less relevant than the political difference between the groups.The dominant strand of Yemeni Shi'ism, Zaydism, is much closer to Sunni practices than it is to what is practiced in Iran or Iraq.

It is here that the US can do the most good.By stepping back militarily and helping Yemen's structural problems, it will be able to been seen as a more honest and benign friend, and not further the central government's legitimacy crisis.By aiding Yemen's underlying fault lines- the country is running out of oil, water, and money- we can help to stave off the catastrophe of state failure, and give the government more breathing room to deal with both al-Qaeda and the other, far more dangerous rebellions.

This is impossible, though, if we treat it like Afghanistan.Even suggesting the comparison brings up an unavoidable debate.Troops are successful, and justifiable in Afghanistan.So that makes the discussion start with military action, instead of taking that reckless and self-defeating option off the table from the get-go. When we look backwards, we will inevitably stumble.

Brian O'Neill, a former writer and editor at The Yemen Observer, is currently an independent analyst and Yemen security expert based out of Chicago. He has been published on Yemen in a number of journals, and with Gregory Johnsen runs the Yemen-obsessive blog, Waq al-Waq. Brian's email is cairobrian@gmail.com



Download Brian O''Neill's color photo - Download Brian O''Neill's black and white mug shot photo
Why not run a cartoon with the column? We recommend the cartoons below as a good compliment to Brian O''Neill's topic.
Click on the thumbnail images to preview and download the cartoons.

Related Cartoons

Scarf
By: Petar Pismestrovic

January 7, 2010

The Era Of The BODY SCANNER
By: Patrick Chappatte

January 11, 2010

Dick World - Terrorism and Republicans Color
By: Pat Bagley

January 4, 2010

Dick World - Terrorism and Republicans
By: Pat Bagley

January 4, 2010

 Lib  Unhinged Drone-COLOR
By: R.J. Matson

January 7, 2010

 Lib  Unhinged Drone
By: R.J. Matson

January 7, 2010

Barack Obama
By: Taylor Jones

December 13, 2009

Yemen
By: David Fitzsimmons

January 6, 2010

Yemen
By: David Fitzsimmons

January 6, 2010

Franchise Opportunities of 2010
By: Bill Schorr

January 7, 2010

Future COLOR
By: Cameron Cardow
The Ottawa Citizen
December 16, 2009

Future BW
By: Cameron Cardow
The Ottawa Citizen
December 16, 2009

Al-Qaida
By: Pavel Constantin

January 4, 2010

Al-Qaida COLOR
By: Pavel Constantin

January 4, 2010

Obama blasts US security
By: Peter Broelman

January 5, 2010

We do not accept and will not review unsolicited submissions from cartoonists.
Sales & Information: (805) 969-2829 sales@cagle.com
Billing Information: (805) 969-2829billing@cagle.com
Technical Support: support@cagle.com

FREE cartoons for your website if you're already a paying print subscriber!
Artwork and columns are copyrighted by each creator. All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized reproduction prohibited. [Privacy Policy]